Pink Poogle Toy Forum

Definitely Dumbledore and Grindy was a lot more surprising- I just never saw that coming. just because there weren't really many cannon hints (even though in hindsight, it does make sense!). In contrast- the Snape/Lily theory wasn't really a surprise. It has been circulating in the potterverse since book 5 (Snape's Worst Memory had a few clues!)- or possibly even earlier (in the first few books, Snape would always insult James but never ever talked about/mentioned Lily, or even "parents" in general- too painful?). There was even the persues evans (yeah I know, spelt incorrectly, but still xD)/severus snape anagram.

As for Aberforh and the goat- that's in a league of it's own xD

Half-Blood Prince or Deathly Hallows?

Hallows. HBP was very good, but it didn't have the sheer drama of DH.

Kreacher or Winky?

_________________

Winky -- she's just so pitiful

Buckbeak or Crookshanks?

_________________

Blue graffitied on my signature... But it made me laugh, so it's all good!

They are both pretty boring, but I'll choose Buckbeak.

Flying cars or flying motorbikes?

_________________

[Manufactured by Byakuya San]

Flying cars - more entertaining

Crabbe or Goyle?

_________________

It was an honor serving you PPT. I will miss you.
Click here to join my new werewolf forum!

Crabbe, poor kid.

Howlers or Remembralls?

_________________

[Manufactured by Byakuya San]

Remembralls. I like my shame to be private.

Fudge or Scrimgeour?

_________________

Scrimgeour. At least he was (allegedly) nice to Harry.

Madame Rosmerta or Madame Puddifoot?

_________________

[Manufactured by Byakuya San]

Rosmerta. Puddifoot only showed up once, and even then, she was barely tolerable.

Albus or Kingsley for Minister? (hypothetically speaking)

_________________

Kingsley- Albus wouldn't have made a great minister imo, mostly because he just didn't want the job, but also because even he has been tempted by power/greed in the past (unlike Harry). Besides, Kingsley is a trained auror and has more ministry experience.

Fleur Delacour or Viktor Krum?

Fleur Delacour. Krum was annoying and Fleur is a Weasley!

Lockhart or Umbridge?

_________________

[Manufactured by Byakuya San]

Lockhart -- Umbridge is way more dangerous (especially now)

Tonks or Shacklebolt?

_________________

Blue graffitied on my signature... But it made me laugh, so it's all good!

Shacklebolt. He's so awesome (and I've never liked Tonks)

The dragon beneath Gringotts or the dragons in the Triwizard Tournament?

_________________

[Manufactured by Byakuya San]

The one beneath Gringotts- it was blind , and actually ended up helping them instead of the other way around!
Levicorpus or Sectumsempra?

Sectumsempra (if you're going to do something, do it right)

The Burrow or Number 12, Grimauld Place?

_________________

[Manufactured by Byakuya San]